Got the following email from the Duncan Hunter campaign this afternoon.
Presidential Candidate Duncan Hunter calls for Sen. Reid to Resign
(Alpine, California) April 27 . . . Rep. Duncan Hunter called Wednesday for Sen. Harry Reid, D-Nevada to resign his post as Senate majority leader. The call came after the Senator's remarks that the war in Iraq is already lost.
Hunter, the ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee and a candidate for President of the United States wrote in a letter that Reid's comments "can have no effect but to demoralize the brave men and women, who are honorably fulfilling their mission in Iraq, and to encourage our adversaries." Hunter continued, "Even if you sincerely believe it to be true, your pronouncement of failure will undoubtedly be used by terrorist leaders to rally their followers - inevitably leading to increased attacks on U.S. and coalition forces."
Hunter wrote "In my opinion Sen. Reid, is having a demoralizing effect on our troops and, in effect, is encouragement our adversaries. I think it's appropriate for Sen. Reid to resign his position as the leader of the United States Senate."
Reid made his remarks Thursday, prompting an angry backlash from Republicans. Senate Democrats also appear embarrassed by Reid's comments and have not publicly issued statements expressly agreeing with Reid's remark. In his letter, Hunter said that lawmakers need to give the surge of troops a chance. "Currently, there are about 146,000 U.S. troops in Iraq. When the reinforcement operation is at full strength, this number will stand at approximately 157,000. How can anyone, including a United States Senator, possibly declare as a failure a reinforcement operation that is less than fifty percent complete?" added Hunter.
Hunter wrote that he has always considered Reid a friend, but that "my highest obligation is to our forces in uniform, especially during this time of war."
"Given your position of leadership within the United States Government, I find your pronouncement of failure irresponsible and disserving to America's armed forces. In light of the fact that this statement has both been used by our adversaries and has exhibited a marked lack of leadership to U.S. troops, I call on you to resign your leadership position," concluded Hunter.
Hunter said "General Petraeus made it very clear that while we are making progress, he portrays this as a difficult challenge and didn't try to sugar-coat the issue and the problems that face the American forces there," and noted that comments like that made by Reid provide incentive for U.S. adversaries.
"It must come as a shock to our enemy to have an aide come into their safe house and tell them that Senator Reid has declared that, in fact, they are winning and the war is lost," Hunter said. "I think it's highly irresponsible for the leader of the U.S. Senator to have said that and, just speaking for myself as the ranking Republican on the Armed Services Committee, I think that the leader of the Senate should step down from that position."
###
Why exactly should Reid resign? Because he actually dared to say what a lot of people are starting to think? I'm also getting sick and tired of the whole semi-fascist "belittling the troops" argument. I'll risk a treason charge from Mr. Hunter and suggest that it hurts our troops far more to send them to war based on bad intelligence and without proper planning than to suggest that such a war can't be won.
I also have to comment on how sadly ironic it is that this is all taking place 4 years after the whole "Mission Accomplished" speech.